top of page

Who Really Decides Your Upgrade at Marriott

Writer: Mirko La Rosa
Mirko La Rosa
3 days ago
6 min read

In short: at Marriott, as at most luxury hotels, an upgrade is a decision made by a person. Usually it's the receptionist, sometimes the general manager. Elite status gives you a claim, but since May 2025 Marriott's own terms promise only an upgrade subject to availability on arrival, no longer the best room left. What tips the balance is what the hotel knows about you before you reach the desk: who you booked with, whether someone called ahead, and whether the people looking after you have noticed you. Here's how upgrades really get decided, and what you can do about it.


IN THIS ARTICLE


Who actually decides your upgrade

Atrium with chandeliers at JW Marriott Istanbul Bosphorus

Most people imagine a system: software that sorts guests by status and hands out suites in order. Status does count, and big hotels assign many rooms in advance. But at the moment you arrive, the decision sits with a person.


In my experience, the upgrade is decided by the receptionist in most cases, or by the general manager when they know someone is arriving. That second part is the one guests rarely think about. A general manager can only look after a guest they know is coming.


So there's a trick I sometimes use for my clients. I call the hotel 20 minutes before the client checks in and say: "This person is arriving, they're a VIP client, please treat them with particular care." At this level of hotel, they usually add something, or they give an upgrade.


It works because the person at the desk makes a quick decision with little information. Anything that tells them who you are, before you're standing in front of them, changes that decision.


What Marriott's own rules promise

For Marriott Bonvoy members, there is a written benefit. Platinum Elite members and above receive a complimentary upgrade, subject to availability upon arrival, for the entire length of the stay. As One Mile at a Time explains in its guide to the policy, until May 2025 the same terms promised the best available room. Now they promise an upgrade, and it doesn't have to be the best one that's free.


The same guide, by Ben Schlappig (published November 2025, updated March 2026), describes a pecking order among elite members. A suite that still looks available in the app may already be set aside for a guest with higher status, and hotels often assign elite rooms the night before or earlier. He also finds hotels outside the US more generous than those inside it, and notes that some properties upgrade only when a guest asks.


So status gets you into the conversation, and the person at the desk still chooses which upgrade, and for whom.


Where you book changes how you're treated

Who you booked with matters a lot. This is really important. If you book with the big platforms, like Booking.com, you're one of many. If you book through a private platform, a private travel agent or a personal concierge, you get a different treatment. That's simply how it works.


That leaves three realistic ways to arrive at a Marriott hotel, and each suits a different traveller.


A big public booking site is the easy option. You find the room fast, and that's it: nobody has told the hotel anything about you, so you arrive as a name on the arrivals list.


Booking direct with Bonvoy status suits someone who stays with Marriott often enough to build it. You get the written benefit above, with its limits and its queue, and you're competing with every other elite guest checking in that day.


Booking through someone with a relationship with the hotel suits the traveller who moves between brands and rarely builds status anywhere. A private platform, an agent or a concierge can let the hotel know who's coming before you get there, which is exactly the information the desk is missing. Luxintravels VIP is our private platform, and if you want to understand where private rates come from, read how private hotel rates work.


How to ask at check-in

Before you arrive, check the app for what's still open on your dates. If suites or higher room categories are available that night, an upgrade costs the hotel very little, and you can mention it with confidence.


Ask at check-in, while the agent is pulling up your booking. That's the moment they're looking at the room plan anyway. Ask for one category up, not the best suite in the house: a small request is easy to say yes to. And use their name. It's on the badge.


A simple way to put it: "I see you still have suites open tonight. If a one-category upgrade is possible, I'd really appreciate it." You ask for little, and you treat them like people.


If the answer is no, be gracious about it. The hotel may be full, or, as the elite pecking order shows, the suite may already be held for someone else. Asking politely never costs you the next stay.


Tip at the start, not at the end

The mistake I see even experienced travellers make with staff is tipping at the end. Always tip at the start. Always, always, always at the start. That's the advice I give: find the person who's looking after you, the one who'll be by your side, tip them straight away, let them get to know you, and stand out from the crowd.


A tip at the end is a thank-you for a stay that's already over. A tip at the start tells the people looking after you that you've noticed them, while the whole stay is still ahead. The point is to get noticed by the people who decide how your stay goes.


The survey: a thank-you that lasts

After a stay, Marriott may send you a Guest Satisfaction Survey by email. According to Marriott's Verified Guest Reviews FAQ, a completed survey is posted word for word on Marriott.com as a Verified Guest Review, and you can only write one if you received the survey after a completed stay.


Not every stay brings one. Marriott's guest feedback page says surveys go out only after you stay, and no more than once every 60 days. So when it does arrive, use it. Name the person who looked after you. A good review with a name in it stays on the hotel's page, where everyone, the team included, can read it.


My take: the real upgrade is being known

Most of the hotels I go to understand that I'm an important guest, and they try to make the whole stay as smooth as possible. Some welcome you to a standard. Others go the extra mile: a handwritten welcome note, or something special for a birthday or an anniversary, done without you saying a word. For the hotel, that extra costs very little. For the guest, it's what makes the difference in what they remember.


I arrived in Rome at Hotel de la Ville. The doorman opened the taxi and said: "Mister Mirko, welcome." They had never seen me. That's when a hotel makes you feel important. And the point is that a hotel should do this for every guest, not only for someone like me. All guests are important. A luxury hotel should always include at least one extra touch that makes a guest feel unique, something that goes beyond simply receiving them.


In a luxury hotel you shouldn't have to think about anything: zero effort. When the staff call you by name as you arrive, people who have never seen you, you remember it forever.


An upgrade is one of those touches. The hotels that give them well are the ones that knew you were coming, and the guests who get them are the ones the desk already knows something about.


If you want to see what a Marriott upgrade can look like, read our stay at JW Marriott Istanbul.


Have you ever been upgraded without asking, or only when you asked?


bottom of page